In an era when investors scrutinize every line of a proxy statement and every dollar of dilution, public companies are increasingly turning to vote projections to navigate the choppy waters of proxy season. These probabilistic forecasts, built on data, governance insight, and disciplined scenario analysis, while remarkably accurate these are not promises of outcomes but powerful decision-support tools. They help boards, counsel, and corporate secretaries chart a course that aligns management’s strategic objectives with what shareholders are likely to approve.

Purpose:  To provide a shareholder vote sensitivity analysis of potential outcomes of ballots items including shareholder proposals, approval of equity compensation plans and increases in capital among other proposals.

What is a vote projection: A vote projection is a structured analysis  that combines a company’s specific shareholder base, historical voting patterns, proxy advisors firms guidelines and influence, and proposal specifics, Typically a company will want to run a few projection scenarios as many proposals will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis by the proxy advisory firms and shareholders.

Ultimately, a vote projection will tell you whether a proposal is likely to pass a shareholder vote.  In addition, a strong projection will give you a close sense of what the likely vote outcome is likely to be.

When are vote projections used:  A vote projection can be used on any ballot item that is put before shareholders but in Alliance Advisor’s experience the three most common ballot items are equity compensation plans, proposals submitted by shareholders, and increases in authorized capital.

Equity Plan Proposals

Equity plan proposals (whether asking for new shares or an entirely new plan) are one of the most important ballot items put before shareholders. Performing a vote projection is an important step in the planning process.  A projection analysis will inform you of the influence of ISS and how critical their support will be on the proposal…spoiler….rarely is ISS outcome determinative.  Just as importantly, a projection will allow you to zero in on the number of shares your specific shareholder base is likely to support.

Benefits for Equity Plan Proposals

Vote projections serve as an early warning system to identify potential opposition before the actual vote. They allow time to address potential shareholder policy concerns and modify the proposal and disclosure which reduces the risk of the proposal failing a shareholder vote.

They provide the foundation for targeted engagement and proposal optimization by pinpointing specific institutional investors likely to vote against. This in turn provides data to adjust the equity plan terms as disclosure to maximize shareholder support. In some cases, vote projections can indicate to management that they can seek more shares than originally proposed.

Proposals Submitted by Shareholders

Proposals submitted by shareholders are often nuisances for management but should not be taken lightly. Typically, companies want to see what the base line support would be to determine if the proposal will pass or fail, and what the likely vote outcome will be.  This will help determine the appropriate proxy solicitation strategy.

Benefits for Proposals Submitted by Shareholders

Based on the expected level of shareholder support it helps gauge whether aggressive opposition, neutral stance, or acceptance is appropriate and prevents under-estimating support for proposals that may pass.

Vote projections can also help with the overall proxy statement strategy and positioning of the proposal. It provides data to help craft more persuasive “Vote AGAINST” rationale based on shareholder sentiment, and voting support levels, and identifies specific concerns to address in opposition statement. It can also help determine if voluntary adoption of proposal elements could defuse support.

Capital Raises

Increases in capital ballot items seek to increase authorized shares or cover private placements over 20 percent of the outstanding shares. Vote projections in this area can mean life or death for a capital starved company, particularly small and mid-cap companies

Benefits for Capital Raise Proposals

For capital raises, certainty that the proposal will be approved by shareholders is the single most important benefit. Companies can reduce execution risk and enable better timing decisions by gauging shareholder support in advance. In addition, data gleaned from the research can help in identifying acceptable dilution thresholds which help with structuring terms (warrants, conversion ratios, discounts) that maximize approval odds.

For exchange-listed companies requiring shareholder approval (e.g., >20 percent dilution under NYSE/Nasdaq rules) it helps determine if private placement or registered offering is a more viable option.

For capital starved companies a vote projection can help avoid failed offerings that damage market credibility. It can also help minimize legal and advisory costs from drawn-out campaigns and proxy solicitation cost associated with failed votes requiring re-solicitation.

Summary

Vote projections are a valuable tool for gauging the success of any type of ballot item. They provide boards and management with actionable data on the likelihood of success, proxy solicitation strategy, and demonstrates due diligence to board members and supports informed decision making. For companies looking to achieve certainty going into it shareholder meeting they should reach out to Alliance Advisors. We have a demonstrable track record of delivering accurate vote projections.