Skip to content
한 걸음 더 나아가기: Shareholder Meetings

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are among the most significant events in corporate strategy—impacting buyers, sellers, and executives navigating these high-stakes deals. In 2024 alone, M&A activity reached $3.5 trillion globally, and with a business-friendly administration, deal volumes may rise even further. However, successful M&As require meticulous planning and strategic to overcome potential opposition and secure a smooth transaction.

From understanding shareholder dynamics to targeting key investors, executives must be proactive ahead of crucial proxy votes, as shareholder dissatisfaction can derail deals before they close. In an environment where activist investors and public scrutiny can quickly shift sentiment, securing shareholder approval demands a well-executed strategy.

Key Do’s and Don’ts for M&A Shareholder Votes

1

Don’t Assume You Have the Vote—Know Your Shareholders

An M&A deal’s success hinges on executives having a clear picture of their shareholder base, which evolves rapidly once a deal is announced. A 2019 study revealed hedge fund ownership in takeover targets increased by 7%, while mutual fund ownership declined by 3%. Stock surveillance, or Ownership Intelligence, is essential to track investor movements and sentiment in real time.

By leveraging advanced ownership intelligence tools, executives can:

  • Identify who is buying and selling shares post-announcement
  • Refine messaging to engage record-date shareholders effectively
  • Assess how investor sentiment shifts before and after the vote
2

Don’t Assume All Investors Support the Deal—Solicitation Strategies Matter

Even with a premium offer, not all investors will automatically back the transaction. Effective solicitation requires distinguishing between retail investors and institutional shareholders:

  • Retail investors prefer clear, simple messaging that highlights direct financial benefits
  • Institutional investors focus on long-term strategy, economies of scale, and margin improvements

Tailored messaging from CEO’s and investor perception studies help ensure that companies align communication strategies with shareholder expectations.

3

Don’t Overlook Sell-Side Analysts—They Shape Market Sentiment

Too often, companies overlook the role of sell-side analysts during an M&A transaction. But these individuals are regularly in front of your investors, and when properly briefed, they can be invaluable in helping shape market perception. If analysts misunderstand or misinterpret the transaction, that misunderstanding can trickle into the shareholder base – especially for institutional investors who lean on analyst notes for quick takes.

To prevent misinterpretation, companies should:

  • Hold dedicated analyst calls separate from general investor communications
  • Provide clear, detailed materials on deal rationale, synergies, and financials
  • Ensure analysts fully understand the strategic vision behind the merger.
4

Don’t believe your shareholder base has remained static. Once the deal has been announced the shareholder base will shift radically and rapidly. Do Pay Attention to Shareholder Base Shifts—Stock Loan Analysis is Critical

Every company that announces an M&A transaction, especially stock for stock deals or deals where there is significant arbitrage, must conduct a stock loan analysis to identify the top institutions lending out shares to short sellers and assess how this impacts the votable share positions.

This analysis helps ensure an accurate understanding of voting dynamics and highlights any potential reductions in voting power caused by this practice.  Why is this important?  Because a large institution like Vanguard or Blackrock might report a significant stake in your company’s stock. However, since they both actively engage in securities lending, a portion of those shares could be out on loan and are no longer eligible to vote.  This effectively reduces the voting power of that institution on its reported record date position.  This can negatively affect a proxy solicitation

  • Conduct a stock loan analysis early and ongoing to assess the impact on votable share positions.
  • Adjust solicitation strategies to compensate for potential reductions in voting power caused by large institutions lending shares to short sellers.
  • Record date institutional shareholdings can be deceiving with stock lending present. Avoid last-minute surprises by monitoring changes in institutional holdings throughout the process.
5

Do Take a Proactive Approach — This is Not a Routine Shareholder Meeting

M&A votes demand an all-hands-on-deck approach. Activist investors are a constant threat, and in H2 2024, over half of all activist campaigns included M&A demands. Public opposition can range from critical statements to full-scale proxy fights, as seen when Brookfield’s $10.6 billion takeover bid for Australia’s largest power retailer was rejected in 2023 due to activist pressure.

  • Engage proactively with all investors—activists often leverage undecided votes to disrupt deals.
  • Ensure proxy solicitation and teams are aligned well before the record date working together on coordinated shareholder outreach.
  • In all M&A transactions a company should have their regular proxy solicitor and IR firm on board. Don’t switch up your team, now is not the time to be holding  the hand of a new firm.
6

Do Include Retail Shareholders in Your Strategy — They Can Make or Break the Vote

Retail shareholders, particularly NOBO (Non-Objecting Beneficial Owners), often determine the success or failure of a vote. Many companies that struggled to secure approval have relied on retail investors to push them over the necessary threshold.

  • Develop retail outreach campaigns early—these efforts require time to be effective.
  • Understand that, when engaged, retail investors tend to support management at high rates.
  • Allocate resources to a targeted retail solicitation strategy to maximize voter turnout.

Conclusion: Ensuring a Smooth M&A Vote

M&A shareholder votes should not fail—but they do. For executives, a failed vote can derail months of planning, strategic vision, and careers. The key to success lies in a comprehensive approach that integrates:

  • Best-in-class Ownership Intelligence to track investor sentiment.
  • End-to-end shareholder engagement tailored to diverse investor types.
  • Focused investor relations strategies to counter opposition and build support.

By embracing these best practices, companies can navigate M&A shareholder votes with confidence—ensuring successful, dispute-free transactions.

Article by

  • Head shot of Sam Chandoha
    Chief Marketing Officer & Head of Corporate Affairs

    With decades of entrepreneurial and direct industry experience Sam is uniquely poised to provide strategic advice on business development, acquisitions and global expansion.

    View all posts
기사 작성자
더 많은 기사

Unseen activist: continuous shareholder surveillance in small and mid-cap healthcare

For a small- or mid-cap public company, an activist campaign rarely appears out of nowhere. The warning signs are often…

The Currency of Trust – How board behavior shapes market confidence.

Institutional investors increasingly evaluate boards by the coherence and candor of the company’s narrative around oversight and long-term value creation…

KraneShares Replaces Proxy Solicitor Mid-Campaign

After adjourning a special shareholder meeting four times due to insufficient votes, KraneShares this month replaced Broadridge with Alliance Advisors…

As ETF acquisitions mount, fund proxy voting becomes a growing headache for asset managers

As M&A deals are continuing to ramp up in the asset management industry, there is also a growing friction point…

Alliance Advisors의 ‘Going Beyond’ 연구 시리즈를 통해 기업 지배구조, 임원 보상, ESG, 주주 행동주의, 개인 투자자 대상 마케팅 및 M&A 분야를 형성하는 핵심적인 논의와 콘텐츠를 중점적으로 다룹니다.

뉴욕 • 워싱턴 D.C. • 토론토 • 밴쿠버
런던 • 더반 • 타이베이 • 홍콩 • 서울

뉴욕

800 3rd Ave 17층
뉴욕
뉴욕 10022

Get in touch

글로벌 본사

오버룩 코퍼레이트 센터
클로브 로드 150번지, 스위트 400
리틀 폴스, 뉴저지 07424

Get in touch

유럽 본부

타워 42
올드 브로드 스트리트 25번지
런던, EC2N 1HN

Get in touch

아시아 태평양 본부

23/F One Chinachem Central,
22 Des Voeux Road Central,
홍콩 센트럴

Get in touch

캐나다

400 – 22 E 5번가
밴쿠버, BC V5T 1G8

Get in touch

얼라이언스 어드바이저스(Alliance Advisors)는 글로벌 네트워크를 통해 주주총회 자문, 주주 참여, 보상, 지배구조 및 지속가능성 서비스를 전문으로 하는 독립 자문 회사입니다.

당사는 대담하고 고객 중심의 전략을 수립부터 실행에 이르기까지 한 차원 더 높은 수준으로 추진하여 성공적인 결과를 이끌어냅니다.

서비스

문의하기